***Our bakery is currently closed to the public Sunday-Friday (aside from pre-order pickups) and only open for walk-ins on Saturdays! You can find all the info on how to pre-order whole cakes and treats by clicking the "order cakes" tab and the "saturday treat pre-orders" tab in the main menu. Please note that we always require a minimum of 5 full days notice for whole cake orders***

Saturday Treat Pre-Orders

  Our weekly treat pre-orders go live on this page every Saturday at 10am for ✨same day pickup ✨ at our bakery in between 11am and 3pm! 

All items will be listed as "sold out" until we manually add the inventories of each item--just refresh this page at 10am and everything will become available. 


Our September Cup-Cake Flavors (available through 9/22):


🖤 PB&J




🖤 Plus our signature COOKIE MONSTER (available year round!) 


NUTTER BUTTERis our September cake slice flavor of the month!



A small check box will pop up at checkout that requires you to agree to our no-show & refund policy before placing your order! That policy is listed below:  

*** Since our treats are baked fresh, have a limited shelf life, and are being held just for you until closing time, all sales are final and there are no refunds for no-shows, late/forgotten pickups, or same day cancellations. By placing your order, you are agreeing to pick up your treats same day in between our set hours. We do not stay past our set hours to accommodate late pickups and are closed completely on Sundays, so if you don't arrive to pick up your treats by 3:15 (closing time), your treats will be held until the following week. Please reach out right away via email to piepiemydarling@gmail.com (NO social media DMs please) if any issues come up so we can work out an alternate pickup date.***




Our cakes are delicate and made with vegan buttercream that positively WILL MELT if left out of the fridge in hot weather. Please take care to keep your cup-cakes cool during transit (we suggest cranking the A/C in your car or bringing a cooler/ice packs) and make sure to refrigerate as soon as you're home. Especially on extra hot summer days, do not leave your cakes in your car or outside for more than a few minutes without air-conditioning. We are not responsible for damage to your treats once they leave our bakery!


Once you arrive at the bakery--located at 2636 W Chicago Ave--come on inside and tell us your ORDER NUMBER(S) (listed in your confirmation email(s), and we will hand your treats off to you!  

***if you also ordered a whole cake, please make sure to let us know. Your orders will show up separately in our system***



Click on each item for descriptions + shelf life/storage instructions. All items are 100% VEGAN!


Don't want to pre-order? Feel free to swing on by in between 11am and 3pm on Saturdays for first come first serve. Some items may sell out to pre-order, so check the live inventory on this page to see which items are still in stock before you head over!