***Our bakery is currently closed to the public Sunday-Friday (aside from pre-order pickups) and only open for walk-ins on Saturdays! You can find all the info on how to pre-order whole cakes and treats by clicking the "order cakes" tab and the "saturday treat pre-orders" tab in the main menu. Please note that we always require a minimum of 5 full days notice for whole cake orders***

Order Cakes!

Please read all of the following information before placing your order. Thanks so much!

🖤Our website will not allow you to book less than FIVE FULL DAYS in advance. Some dates (especially holiday weeks/weekends) may book up fully before the 5 day mark, so the earlier you book, the better 🖤  

The order cutoff for each day is at 3pm, so if you need a cake for pickup on a Saturday, make sure your order is placed before 3pm that Monday!  

We are currently booking cakes through the month of October only. Dates for November will open up on October 20th


Pre-order pickups are at our bakery, located at 2636 W Chicago Ave in Ukrainian Village.

Pickup hours:

🖤Wed-Friday: 12pm-3pm

🖤Saturdays: 11am-3pm

🖤Sunday-Tuesday: CLOSED


There is a grace period of 15 minutes before we close up shop for the day at 3:15.

Cakes must be picked up at our bakery--we do not offer delivery at this time.


Cancellations must be made a minimum of 48 hours (two full days) before your set pickup date. There are no refunds for last minute cancellations, late/forgotten pickups, and no-shows since your cake has a limited shelf life and we are baking it fresh from scratch with love and holding it until closing time just for you! 

Note that our staff are not able to stay past our set hours to accommodate late pickups. Please plan accordingly and take care to show up on time, and if anything comes up on pickup day, email us asap (no social media DM's please) and we’ll do our best to work with you to arrange an alternate pickup date. 

In the event of inclement weather, you can feel free to email us to reschedule your pickup, but we are unable to provide a refund since your treats have a limited shelf life and have already been baked. 

Our Cakes:


All of our cakes/cupcakes are 100% vegan, meaning they are dairy, egg, and animal product-free! Our cakes DO contain wheat, soy, & gluten. Some of our cakes contain peanuts & tree nuts and we cannot guarantee that cross contamination won't occur, so please note that our cakes are NOT safe for those with severe nut allergies. Feel free to email us with questions if there are other allergens you're trying to avoid--we would much rather you be safe than sorry.


We are not a custom cake bakery and instead find joy through baking up our own original cake designs & creations! In order to streamline the ordering process so we can serve as many of you as possible, cakes come exactly as listed and we do not offer custom decorations or writing on cakes.

Note that pricing is subject to change without notice as the prices and availability of our ingredients fluctuates!


If kept refrigerated, most of our cakes will stay fresh and moist for 4-5 days and also freeze great. Click here for storage and transport instructions and again, feel free to email us if you have any questions.



Our cakes are delicate and made with vegan buttercream that positively WILL MELT if left out of the fridge for even a short time in hot weather. Please take care to keep your cake cool during transit (we suggest cranking the A/C in your car or bringing a cooler/ice packs) and make sure to refrigerate as soon as you're home. Especially on extra hot summer days, do not leave your cake in your car or outside for more than a few minutes without air-conditioning. We are not responsible for damage to your cake once it leaves our bakery!


🖤How to place your order 🖤

See our full menu below and click on your desired cake flavor!

Each flavor is available in 6" babycake, 8" full size, or cupcakes by the dozen.

Choose your desired cake size using the drop down menu. When you choose your size, the price listed will adjust accordingly.

Next, choose your pickup date and time using the calendar shown under your item.  

Once your size, flavor, and pickup date and time have been chosen you can add the item to your cart and complete the checkout process. If you'd like to order multiple items, add each item to your cart one at a time and then complete checkout.

There is a re-booking fee for changes made to your order once its been placed so please take your time and make sure everything is right before completing checkout! 

Your order will not be booked until checkout is complete and your payment has been received. As soon as your order has been placed, you will receive a confirmation email which will ensure that your order has been processed. 


Feel free to reach out to us at piepiemydarling@gmail.com (NO social media DM's please) if your confirmation email doesn't come through, or if you have any other questions. Thanks so much loves!


See the first couple of rows for our current seasonal cake flavors! More spooky season cake specials are coming soon...🎃 🦇 🕸️